Risk Management: What Churches Should Be Looking For With Systems Integrators (Part 1)

by | Oct 6, 2022 | AVL Projects, Production

Every AV system project comes with risk. As consultants, we recognize there may be significant unfamiliarity and even considerable anxiety when it comes to selecting and hiring an AV contractor, or systems integrator as they’re often described today.

When private money is in play, it’s a common temptation to skip the professional consultants and choose to work directly with a design/build integrator. But buyer beware: not all systems integrators are created equally.

Paraphrasing what many have said, “I was put in charge of finding an AV contractor and I have little or no idea how to pick one, or what to look for. I’m just hoping that whoever we select knows what they’re doing and won’t rip us off.” Sound familiar? If so, this article will provide guidelines on how integrators can and should manage and minimize the main, definable risk factors. These risks are often not recognized, understood, or openly discussed before signing a contract. They should be.

Even if you plan to hire a professional AV or acoustical consultant, and send your project out for bids, many of the concepts outlined below hold true. Why? Because accepting the low-bid price is rarely the best plan. Again, why? Because even though they may “qualify” on paper, those firms that have the lowest overhead (read: least invested in providing a full spectrum of quality people, products and services) will almost always come in with the lowest bid.

We believe AV integration project risk can be distilled into these three main categories: Technical, non-technical, and intangible. Here we’ll focus on the technical aspect and will discuss the other two in subsequent articles.

Technical risks are those involving the specification, integration, and application of modern AV technology. Today, this is an ever-evolving landscape of compatible and incompatible digital formats and standards. To properly address a customer’s technical needs and risks, we believe the following elements play an important role.

Design & Engineering Team

Does the integrator employ one or more (in house) systems designers and engineers with formal degrees and/or specialized training certifications? Do they use the latest computer-aided design, modeling, and documentation tools such as AutoCAD, Revit, EASE (Figure 1) and Modeler, along with any other proprietary software?

Figure 1: An EASE 3D wireframe models of a new church.

The recommended approach is to fully engineer all projects. This includes 2D and 3D drawings for conduit, backbox and power layouts, rigging details, a certified structural review when applicable, single line diagrams, rack elevations, and plate and panels details.

While using the tools and techniques listed above are common practices for AV consultants, architects, and many of the better general contractors, we realize many end users have never been involved in the intimate details of a construction project and aren’t accustomed to looking at construction specifications and drawings.

The best design/build contractors strive to present their intended integration solutions in ways the general public can easily understand. Customers should be allowed to see their project on paper, or in a computer model as a wireframe, rendering, or virtual walk-though, before it’s built. This allows questions, changes, conflicts, and mistakes to be addressed and resolved early so they cause minimal disruption; resulting in a project that’s more likely to be completed on time and on budget.

Figure 2: A CAD sightline study — note the balcony slope sightline problem with respect to the front platform.

Sign Up for Connections, the Worship Facility Newsletter!

NEW THIS WEEK

Developing Your Contemporary Worship Team Vocals

Once upon a time, churches had no sound systems. The congregation sang their lyrics and sight-read their vocal parts from hymnals. Fast forward to today; most churches are using current technology including sound systems, lighting, presentation software, cameras for...

How to Grow Your Church Tech Team

Another frequent question I was asked at CFX in Dallas was “How to grow your church tech team”.  Having a church tech team is essential to every church. Unfortunately most churches don't know how to grow their tech team. Let me help guide you on how to build a church...

The Metaverse & The Church

How in the world can the metaverse be a place for churches to connect with people? It may be a more viable option than you think!